Taking just over an hour over two sessions, I found this a little harder than your average Jumbo, with a sprinkling of questionmarks and "check" on my paper copy. 27A, 37A, the spelling at 7D and the hall in 38D, were all unknown, although I somehow remembered 26D. A good few approving ticks too.... I liked 43A, 51A, 8D and 47D in particular. All rather satisfying and good entertainment. Thank-you setter! How did everyone else get on?
If you were on song, you might have got through this quickly. For me, it was more like ‘slow but steady’. I finished confident of the answers but with lots of questions to look up. Why is a 25ac sensitive? What is a 23ac? Who is 17dn? And more.
I had no obvious clue of the day, but 15ac set the mood of the moment. Thanks to the setter for a very enjoyable puzzle.
Clues are blue, with definitions underlined. (ABC*) means ‘anagram of ABC’. Deletions are in [square brackets]. The blog is in Times New Roman font, as part of an ongoing, gentle campaign to urge the club site to use a font in which it is easier to tell one’s stem from one’s stern.
1 Arrived shortly, turning up with son for college (6)
CAMPUS – CAM[e]. PU=UP ‘turning’, S[on].
5 Brilliance of girl shown endlessly in competition (8)
RADIANCE – DIAN[a] in RACE.
9 Partial metaphor is misplaced in a maxim (8)
APHORISM – hidden answer.
10 Casually play with pasta (6)
NOODLE – double definition. ‘Noodling’ is apparently casual improvisation in jazz.
11 Trendy food shop has to supply food, mostly tasteless (10)
INDELICATE – IN, DELI, CATE[r].
13 Top cover for American district gangster (4)
HOOD – triple definition. Actually, a triple abbreviation: HOOD short for hoodie, HOOD short for neighbourhood, HOOD short for hoodlum!
14 Obese, eating seconds, and not running (4)
FAST – S in FAT. The answer is one of those cute words with exactly opposite meanings: moving fast, or tied fast.
15 What rail services need accompanying words and music? (10)
SOUNDTRACK – a light-hearted double definition. You wouldn't want your train running on an unsound track!
18 Broken arrester in device holding something back (10)
RESTRAINER – (ARRESTER IN*), ‘broken’.
20 Cat and comb ultimately makes catacomb? (4)
TOMB – TOM, [com]B.
21 Deep sea fish, black when small (4)
BASS – B[lack], AS, S[mall].
23 Surveyor’s instrument — they cart me about (10)
TACHYMETER – (THEY CART ME*), ‘around’. Apparently, it’s a surveying device that uses rangefinder technology.
25 Am keeping notes about sensitive plant (6)
MIMOSA – AM ‘keeping’ SO and MI, all backwards (‘about’). Apparently mimosa leaves may respond to touch.
26 Very poor walkway state getting turned round (8)
PATHETIC – PATH, CITE ‘turned around’.
28 Briefly immerse pot for small plant (8)
DUCKWEED – DUCK, WEED. Tempting to think WEE=small, but no, I think WEED=pot, and duckweed is just a small plant!
29 Good, I am allowed a cocktail (6)
GIMLET – G[ood], I’M, LET.
2 Await developments in a leaf attachment (9)
APPENDAGE – PEND in A PAGE.
3 School research task needs to stand out (7)
PROJECT – double definition.
4 Mountain runner regularly visited Sikkim (3)
SKI – odd letters of SiKkIm.
5 Dance of millions in Cuba — right for clubs (5)
RUMBA – M for millions in CUBA with C for clubs replaced by R for right.
6 Race to put on vital headgear (6,5)
DONKEY DERBY – DON, KEY, DERBY.
7 One further person yet to be named (7)
ANOTHER – um, *another* double definition.
8 Transparent sheet left over instrument (5)
CELLO – CEL (short for celluloid, I discover), L[eft], O[ver].
12 Show a case for taking fast before one took food (11)
INSTANTIATE – INSTANT, I, ATE.
16 Uniform used on Royal Navy vessel (3)
URN – U[niform], R.N.
17 Caught rewritten line by me in play (9)
CYMBELINE – C[aught], (LINE BY ME*), ‘rewritten’. Cymbeline was a king of early Britain, in a Shakespeare play. Lucky I looked that up! Did anyone else guess French, female?
19 What stands up like this out of hot footwear? (7)
TUSSOCK – T[h]US (like this), SOCK.
20 Member in the House that is born in Chelsea, perhaps (3,4)
TIE BEAM – I.E. (that is), B (born) in TEAM.
22 Parting device for stamping coins in gold (5)
ADIEU – DIE in AU.
24 Young archer finished in police department (5)
CUPID – UP in C.I.D.
27 Wicket perhaps overturned endlessly in game (3)
TAG – GAT[e], ‘overturned’.
I was thinking that the one thing this excellent, exceedingly entertaining puzzle lacked—besides an &lit (but I’d rather have none at all than a “semi”-one, to tell you the truth)—was a bit of unusual, borderline-Mephisto vocabulary that I could discover for the very first time through the art of decryption. Here the most interesting word, taken in isolation, seemed to be 4. But I was overlooking 16, which I had gotten quickly but which might be rarer, and which even, though its derivation is a bit obscure, may tie in (as I have just now discovered while doing the final edits here) with clue 19.
Seeing X and Z on opposite corners, and W and Y sticking out on the edges as well, made me wonder if this was a pangram, and, lo, so it is.
I do (anasargm)* like this, and italicize anagrinds in the clues.
|1||Times writing about a festival (4)|
|XMAS — Times is X, with M(A)S. Too early!|
|4||In shops, woman and daughter hold hands? (10)|
|STEVEDORES — ST(EVE)(D)ORES They work in the cargo holds of ships. I don’t think the quirk is necessary, but it may have helped someone. The word entered the languge (says Wikipedia) through its use by sailors, and started as a phonetic spelling of estivador (Portuguese) or estibador (Spanish).|
|9||Cheated and voted twice (6-7)|
|DOUBLE-CROSSED — This week’s Public Service Announcement: Election fraud is actually very rare in the United States. CD (though no quirk) along with the straight one.|
|10||Film director needing an ending went overboard (4,2)|
|FELL IN — I’ve seen a few flicks like that. FELLIN[-i] Wins my nod for COD.|
|11||Design surrounding emblem is oddly vulgar (8)|
|PLEBEIAN — PLAN corralling the odd letters of EmBlEm Is, which latter element is very cleverly disguised|
|12||Academic rooms for recording university dons (8)|
|STUDIOUS — STUDIO(U)S Bob has a knack for inverting the usual grammar in the cryptic to throw one off the track. (I’ve recorded in my apartment, but that’s not why it’s called a studio.)|
|14||It’s lucky the old lady has somewhere to sleep (6)|
|MASCOT — MA’S COT This is more of a strong hint than a definition, strictly speaking, though it’s a stronger hint than what passes for a definition in 19. (I’m not complaining.)|
|15||Agreed to a German weapon after it’s cut a gemstone (6)|
|JASPER — ”Agreed[,] to a German,” JA + SPE[-a]R|
|17||Girl this writer recalled in prayers (8)|
|ROSEMARY — ROS(ME<=)ARY|
|19||With less fluid they sometimes contain peas (8)|
|WHISTLES — (with less)* Although I fancy myself a musician, I never knew that the little stone-like object found inside whistles that warble is called a “pea.”|
|21||When to start to seek first aid (6)|
|ASSIST — AS, “when” + S[-eek] + I(1)ST, “first”|
|23||Put an end to bank sheltering stray dog (6,7)|
|SCOTCH TERRIER — SCOTCH, “put an end to” + T(ERR)IER|
|24||Like one separating people making spiteful remarks (10)|
|ASPERSIONS — ”Like,” AS + PERS(I)ONS|
|25||An Olympian retired somewhere in Egypt (4)|
|SUEZ — ZEUS<=”retired”|
|2||Insect turning up, say, before dark (5)|
|MIDGE — EG, “say” + “dark,” DIM <=”turning up” (I think this works; EG turns up “before” DIM does.)|
|3||Repulsive gang getting in the middle of police (7)|
|SQUALID — SQUA([-po]LI[-ce])D|
|4||Brilliant appearance of sub, over in Tottenham, cut short (9)|
|SPLENDOUR — ”Tottenham” SPUR[-s] with LEND, “sub” + O(ver) inside. After biffing, I somehow got to the bottom of the parsing with little trouble. I must have first Googled “Tottenham.” The relevant UK slang sense for “sub” was found in Cambridge, “to lend someone money until they can pay it back to you“—although in Collins the definition closest to that is a bit different: “to grant or receive (an advance payment of wages or salary).”|
|5||European heads, with coolness, finally admitted leaks (7)|
|ESCAPES — E([-coolnes]S)CAPES|
|6||Scratching insect makes mammal run off (5)|
|ELOPE — [-ant]ELOPE|
|7||Removing the head destroys fresh seafood (7)|
|OYSTERS — ([-d]ESTROYS)*|
|8||Labour aim always to be heard (9)|
|ENDEAVOUR — END, “aim” + “ever,” audibly|
|13||Trains carrying sixty-eight empty boxes (3,6)|
|TEA CHESTS — TEACHE(S[-ixty-eigh]T)S|
|14||Mother cares awfully about sons being butchers (9)|
|MASSACRES — For or against? MA, “mother” + (cares)* around SS, “sons” (In the surface, the possessive-with-gerund rule seems to be, as too often, flouted. Ma cares about their being butchers, right?)|
|16||Old coin shop is to let, but not all of it (7)|
|PISTOLE — Hidden. Dictionaries tell you first that it was the French name for a Spanish coin, but add that the same name was also applied to other French and European coins. Though the term is “of uncertain origin,” it is said to probably come from a Czech word meaning WHISTLE.|
|17||Very dry port overwhelms Italian food (7)|
|RISOTTO — RI(SO TT)O, “dry” being TeeTotaling. Here’s that inverted syntax again.|
|18||Good-looking girl is entertaining weirdos (7)|
|MISFITS — MIS(FIT)S|
|20||Tastes defeats (5)|
|LICKS — DD|
|22||Ages used up wrapping Eastern garment (5)|
|SAREE — E(E)RAS<=”used up” Variant spelling of “sari,” which is, incidentally, an eastern garment.|